Phoenix Coldon was a 23-year-old Black woman from Spanish Lake, Missouri, whose sudden vanishing on December 18, 2011, has baffled investigators, her family, and the public for over a decade. Born Phoenix Reeves on May 23, 1988, in California, she moved to Missouri as a child when her father, Lawrence Coldon, took a new job. Her mother, Goldia (also referred to as Gloria), later married Lawrence, who adopted Phoenix. Largely homeschooled in a strict, religious household, Phoenix excelled academically and extracurricularly—she became the junior fencing champion of St. Louis County, played multiple musical instruments like the piano, and was described as intelligent, outgoing, and talented. By 2011, she was a junior at the University of Missouri-St. Louis, studying microbiology, but had recently moved back in with her parents after a brief period of independence where she rented an apartment—ostensibly with a female friend, though it was actually shared with a secret boyfriend. This detail hints at the double life Phoenix was leading, which would only come to light after her disappearance.

Timeline of the Disappearance

The events of December 18, 2011, unfolded in a seemingly ordinary way. Phoenix and her mother attended morning church services, made a quick stop on the way home, and arrived back at their residence on the 12600 block of Countrybrook Drive around early afternoon. Around 3 p.m., Phoenix took the keys to her mother’s black 1998 Chevy Blazer (sometimes referred to as a Bronco in reports), sat in the driveway for a few minutes while talking on her cell phone, and then drove off without telling her parents where she was going—a departure from her usual habit of informing them of her plans. Her father, Lawrence, watched her leave but assumed she was heading to a nearby convenience store or a friend’s house, as she typically returned by 2 a.m. if out late.

She never came back. Just hours later, at 5:27 p.m., a 911 call reported the Blazer abandoned at the corner of 9th Street and St. Clair Avenue in East St. Louis, Illinois—a roughly 25-minute drive from her home, across state lines in a high-crime area notorious for sex trafficking and violence. Initial reports claimed the vehicle was found with the engine running and the driver’s door open, suggesting a possible abrupt abduction. However, the first responding officer later clarified in a 2018 documentary (with updates reiterated in 2025 coverage) that the engine was off and the door was closed, casting doubt on the original narrative and potentially undermining assumptions of foul play at the scene. The car was impounded by 6:23 p.m. as an “abandoned vehicle,” but police did not run the plates or contact the registered owner, Goldia Coldon.

The family reported Phoenix missing the next day, December 19, but encountered resistance from police, who initially dismissed it because she was an adult over 21. It wasn’t until two weeks later, on January 1, 2012, that a family friend discovered the Blazer in an impound lot. Upon retrieval, the Coldons found Phoenix’s glasses, purse (containing her ID and driver’s license), shoes, and other personal items inside—contradicting police claims that the vehicle was empty and thus not inventoried. DNA testing later confirmed no one besides Phoenix and her parents had been in the SUV. All activity on her bank accounts, cell phone, and social media ceased after her departure.

The Investigation and Criticisms

The St. Louis County Police Department’s handling of the case drew sharp criticism from the Coldons and advocates. The family argued that the two-week delay in notifying them about the vehicle gave any potential perpetrators a significant head start, and that police failed to search the surrounding area or properly process the scene. Media coverage was scant, which the Coldons attributed to racial bias—Phoenix’s case as a missing Black woman received far less attention than similar cases involving white women. They turned to organizations like Black & Missing for help amplifying the story.

Frustrated, the Coldons funded their own searches, hiring private investigators like Steve Foster and a duo named Ness and Andy Weyland. Lawrence scoured abandoned buildings in East St. Louis, while Goldia interviewed sex workers and drug dealers. These efforts drained their life savings and nearly led to foreclosure on their home, exacerbated by a hoax tip from a man in Texas who claimed Phoenix was in a prostitution ring but later admitted it was a scam. A stranger’s donation helped them avoid losing the house. Goldia suffered panic attacks and a heart attack from the stress.

As of October 2025, the case remains unsolved, with no active leads reported. Podcasts like “The Missing” (November 2024) and “Crime Junkie” (2023) continue to profile it, emphasizing that it could still be resolved with new tips. The St. Louis County Police (contact: 314-615-5317) and the family’s Facebook page urge anyone with information to come forward.

Secrets Revealed: Phoenix’s Double Life

Post-disappearance investigations uncovered a side of Phoenix that contrasted sharply with her sheltered upbringing. She had a secret second cell phone for contacting friends and romantic interests her parents might disapprove of. She was in relationships with multiple men, including her secret boyfriend Michael B. (with whom she lived during college) and another man, “Mike #2,” who had a history of violence against women—his ex-girlfriend filed a restraining order and reported him saying, “Why are you worrying about someone who’s dead?” about Phoenix. Investigators cleared Michael B. of involvement but provided no details on Mike #2.

Phoenix also possessed two birth certificates—one under her adoptive name and one under her mother’s maiden name, Reeves—which traced to an address in Anchorage, Alaska, but the person there had no connection to her. A private investigator alleged she took money from her parents’ safe, suggesting she might have planned to flee. Months before vanishing, a “selfie video” showed her expressing mental anguish, isolation, a desire to “start over,” and unhappiness, reciting the Serenity Prayer and asking for divine help. Her best friend and neighbor revealed Phoenix had become paranoid, talked about leaving, feared something bad would happen, and carried a large knife for protection—which was missing from the SUV. She hadn’t enrolled in spring 2012 classes, adding to suspicions of intentional departure.

Theories and Speculations

Three primary theories have dominated discussions, as explored in the 2018 Oxygen documentary “The Disappearance of Phoenix Coldon” and updated in later coverage:

  1. Abduction into Sex Trafficking: The abandonment location near Interstate 70 (dubbed the “human trafficking highway”) in a crime-ridden area supports this. A 2014 sighting by a church friend on a flight from Las Vegas saw a woman resembling Phoenix with other young women and two large men; she responded ambiguously to her name and the group vanished at the airport. The family leans toward this, having searched strip clubs and spoken to prostitutes.
  2. Intentional Runaway or Staged Disappearance: Evidence of her double life, the emotional video, secret relationships, and dissatisfaction with her strict home suggest she left voluntarily to start anew. Investigators increasingly favor this, noting the orderly abandonment and lack of foul play signs. The dual birth certificates and possible stolen money fuel ideas of a new identity.
  3. Foul Play or Murder: Some believe she met harm from someone in her secret circle, like Mike #2, or random violence in East St. Louis. Her paranoia and missing knife suggest she anticipated danger. However, no body or evidence of violence has surfaced.

The 2025 article from Synova Ink emphasizes how discrepancies in initial reports (e.g., engine status) have shifted focus toward the runaway theory, but the family remains convinced of trafficking.

Media Coverage and Broader Implications

Phoenix’s case gained traction through the 2018 Oxygen two-part special, which revealed many secrets and criticized police efforts. It was profiled on podcasts like “The Vanished” (2016), “Crime Junkie” (2023), and “The Missing” (2024), highlighting systemic issues like underreporting of missing Black women. Documentaries and articles, including a 2024 Medium piece questioning if she staged her vanishing, keep the story alive.

 After 14 years, Phoenix’s fate remains a haunting enigma, with her parents’ unwavering search symbolizing hope amid despair. If alive, she would be 37 today.

Privacy Preference Center